If Limbo, why not Hell?
  by Janet Brazill

It's good to know the Catholic Church is evolving. Catholic theologians have now met to consider scrapping the concept of Limbo, the incomplete afterlife postulated by the Roman Catholic church for infants who die before being baptized. Protestant reformers eliminated this idea from their theology in the Middle Ages.

Now, if religions would only do away with the cruel idea of Hell!

The fear of never-ending torment in a lake of fire after death has ruined many lives and has been responsible for unspeakable crimes -- from the Inquisition, where thousands were tortured and converted, then burnt at the stake to rescue their souls from the fires of Hell, to Andrea Yates, who believed in the Devil and killed her children to save them from going to Hell.

Many primitive religions used the threat of punishment after death as a means of controlling believers, although Christianity appears to be the only one that preaches punishment for all of eternity.

Unfortunately, the idea of "Hell" is a handy tool for anyone in authority.

Take the Air Force Academy chaplain who ordered cadets to tell their non-Christian friends that they will "burn in the fires of Hell" if they don't attend Christian worship services. Or Patrick Henry College's requirement that homeschooled students sign a "statement of faith" that Hell is a place where "all who die outside of Christ shall be confined in conscious torment for eternity."

A well-known atheist organization often prints samples of the hate mail it receives. These messages are full of bad language, bad grammar, and wishes that God send all atheists to Hell.

It is clear that this concept appeals to those with a "bully mentality" -- sadists who can take delight in the suffering of others.

Religious bullies are especially dangerous. Blaise Pascal, the 17th Century French mathematician, philosopher and theologian, remarked that "Men never do evil so completely and cheerfully as when they do it from religious conviction."

Voltaire observed: "Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities." Indeed, all crimes committed in the name of religion are based on myths about an afterlife, such as the reward of seventy-two eternal virgins for Muslim suicide bombers, or glorious life in a Christian Heaven for killers of abortion doctors.

Thomas Paine noted: "Of all the tyrannies that affect mankind, tyranny in religion is the worst; every other species of tyranny is limited to the world we live in; but this attempts to stride beyond the grave, and seeks to pursue us into eternity."

Ironically, current surveys show that most Americans disapprove of torture, yet many of those same Americans worship a God who allegedly uses eternal torture as a punishment.

Since the concept of Limbo is now understood as having been devised to console parents whose babies died before they could be baptized, people should be capable of concluding that the idea of Hell was likewise contrived, though with more devious motives. In the early years, the fear of Hell's torment was useful in ensuring compliance with church doctrine. Modern religions, however, learning from psychiatrists that this dogma of damnation can cause some to develop mental disorders, should disavow promoting this barbaric myth.

If the Church can discard the idea of Limbo, why not Hell?

Send us an Email

Or write to us at:
Freethinkers of Colorado Springs
P.O. Box 62946
Colorado Springs, CO 80962-2946
Phone: 719-594-4506