Post Hoc Miracles
by Bruce Monson
Christians today are fond of proclaiming that, even in a world filled with
"sinful" people who "fully deserve to suffer in hell for all eternity,"
Jesus, because he loves us all so much, still performs miracles for us, but
the reason nonbelievers "fail to see" is because we are blinded by arrogance
or deluded by the devil!
|
Isn't it interesting, though, that all of these so-called "miracles" seem to
come in the form of naturally occurring phenomena, or events that have
perfectly natural explanations? For example, if a skyscraper collapses from
an earthquake (or terrorist attack), killing thousands under millions of tons
of concrete and steel, but a few people are rescued from isolated pockets
within the rubble (through human effort, mind you), it's labeled "a miracle
from Jesus" even though it's a statistical probability that a few people will
be alive. While the odds of any particular person surviving such a
catastrophe are exceedingly small, the odds that some will be alive is
virtually 100 percent; as such there is nothing "miraculous" about it!
|
From a post hoc perspective, anything can be made to seem "miraculous."
Because these miracle claims are devised after the fact, and based on a need
to believe that Jesus is real and that he performs miracles, Christians will
latch onto any improbable event that fits a preformed expectation they have
in their minds, but they ignore the thousands of other "improbable events"
they see every day but never notice because they carry no religious weight
for them.
|
This past summer, during a major league baseball game, the famed Arizona
Diamondbacks' pitcher, Randy Johnson, threw a blazing fastball toward home
plate, and at that moment a bird flew in the path of the pitch and was struck
by the ball, which killed it in mid-air. Now, the probability of such an
event happening is remote in the extreme, and yet we don't see Christians
running around proclaiming what a "miracle" it was! They don't call it a
miracle because they have no religious motivation to do so. Besides, they
realize that there was nothing outside the natural world required for this
improbable event to have occurred.
|
So why is it, then, with so many billions of prayers being said year-in and
year-out by millions of Christians all over the world, we have never seen a
"miracle" come in the form of even one resurrection from the dead? In my
profession I have seen many children die tragically, and do you know what?
They are all still dead!
|
Evidently, Jesus' best miracle work comes through death and destruction
(e.g., WTC, Oklahoma City, etc.), but why can't he provide just one
resurrection today as objective evidence to "His" reality? Why not just one
Lazarus (John 11); just one Jairus' daughter (Luke 8); just one "Only son of
a widowed mother" (Luke 7)? Indeed, in the Lazarus fable we are told that
Jesus waited for him to be dead and buried for four days because he thought
it would be a good opportunity to perform a resurrection for his disciples
(and the people standing round) in order "that they may believe..." (John
11:42). Well, why should we expect anything less, so that WE may see it "and
believe"? Why should they get the supposed physical evidence but we, two
millennia removed, "just have to have faith"?
|
Send us an Email
Or write to us at:
Freethinkers of Colorado Springs
P.O. Box 62946
Colorado Springs, CO 80962-2946
Phone: 719-594-4506
|