Read the Warnings Before Taking
A review of: God is not Great:
How Religion Poisons Everthing, by Christopher Hitchens
by Marsha Abelman
It's probable that most conservatives won't read Christopher
Hitchens' book. The title alone could prevent the superstitious from
even touching the book in a bookstore. Hitchens may be the "village
atheist" as the New York Times called him, but if religionists knew
that Hitchens was hostile to Bill Clinton, is an anti-Zionist and
is a supporter of George W's Iraq war, they might be intrigued enough
to tackle this very educational read. |
With chapters like "…Why Heaven Hates Ham," "A Note
on Health, to Which Religion can be Hazardous," "Is Religion Child
Abuse?" and "...Religion's Corrupt Beginnings," the book covers every
aspect of religion's affects on humanity. It will inform believers
and non believers of facts forgotten (or never learned), such as the
list of nine virgin births in religions and mythology, not including
Jesus (page 23). Think we're living in an enlightened age? In chapter
four, the reader learns that Timothy Dwight, an admired minister and
a president of Yale University, opposed the smallpox vaccination because
it [was] "an interference with god's design." The same chapter tells
of newborn boys who died in New York City in 2005, victims of herpes
infections they contracted during religious circumcision rites.
|
Some information in the book will not be a surprise
to the fundamentalists who pride themselves on scripture knowledge.
Moses' order to parents to stone their disobedient children to death,
orders to armies to kill conquered males but keep "women-children
that hath not known a man by lying with him…alive for yourselves,"
contradictory commandments ("Thou shalt not kill" and "Thou shalt
not suffer a witch to live") - these are familiar. However, few churches
spend any time teaching how the book came to be "the Bible" - who
decided which writings to include and which to destroy, when the Bible
was put together (hundreds of years after Jesus allegedly lived),
and the Gnostic gospels' existence. |
After finishing the book, I went online to read some
reviews. One wrote that Hitchens "demonized" religion, another that
he was "picking a fight," and one reviewer said indignantly that Hitchens
calls those he "wishes to ridicule by their zoological class…mammals."
|
Yes, Hitchens gives religion full credit for the bad
it has done; however, the choice of the word "demonize" is interesting,
as atheists do not acknowledge the existence of demons. The reviewer's
word choice demonstrates religion's insidious influence, filling our
world and language with supernatural references. Is Hitchens picking
a fight? It seems that people knocking on doors to distribute unwelcome
religious pamphlets to those who didn't ask for them are spoiling
for a fight much more than a scholar who writes a well-researched
book and leaves it to the public to buy the book or not. The complaint
that Hitchens calls people "mammals" to denigrate them is just wrong.
Humans are mammals, and Hitchens refers to himself as a mammal on
page 76. Religionists might prefer to think of themselves as "immortal
souls." But there is no empirical proof of a "soul," while there's
no denial of our physical nature. Calling a human an animal is not
an insult, it's a scientific fact. |
Hitchens agrees with many of his contemporaries that
religion is so deeply ingrained in societies, it is probably ineradicable.
However, he clearly sees the dangers of this poison we ingest, and
he writes to warn of its lethal properties. |
People may choose to continue ingesting religion, but
here's a chance for consumers to read the product's "warning label."
|
|
Send us an Email
Or write to us at:
Freethinkers of Colorado Springs
P.O. Box 62946
Colorado Springs, CO 80962-2946
Phone: 719-594-4506
|